What is the NAIC complaint index?

A ratio of consumer complaints relative to market share. A score of 1.0 is the national median. Below 1.0 means fewer complaints than expected (good); above 1.0 means more complaints (caution).

Which home insurance company has the fewest complaints?

Erie (0.36), Amica (0.41), State Farm (0.52), and USAA (0.58) have the lowest NAIC home complaint indexes among major U.S. carriers in 2026.

Does a higher J.D. Power score mean my claim will be paid faster?

Generally yes — claims satisfaction correlates strongly with time-to-payment, ease of resolution, and adjuster responsiveness. The top-scoring carriers also have higher repair-vendor density and stronger catastrophe-event claim pipelines.

Should I switch carriers just because mine has a bad review?

Not on the review alone — but combined with a routine renewal price check, a poor claims rating is a good reason to comparison-shop. The cost of switching is near zero; the cost of a bad claims experience is real.

RateRoots Auto Insurance Marketplace

Home insurance company reviews

Independent reviews of the major home insurers — financial strength, claims satisfaction, complaint ratios, and what each does best.

Compare top-rated carriers See bundle savings

Free • No SSN required • Licensed carrier partners

USAA

A.M. Best

A++

J.D. Power Claims

902 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.58 (well below average — excellent)

Pros

✓Lowest rates in segment
✓Highest claims satisfaction
✓Military-family-specific perks

Cons

⚠Limited to military families

Verdict: If you qualify, USAA almost always wins on rate AND service.

Amica Mutual

A.M. Best

A+

J.D. Power Claims

893 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.41 (well below average — excellent)

Pros

✓Industry-leading customer satisfaction
✓Dividend policies return premium
✓Strong claims process

Cons

⚠Smaller agent footprint
⚠Slightly higher base rates

Verdict: Top non-military pick if you care most about claims experience and service.

State Farm

A.M. Best

A++

J.D. Power Claims

884 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.52 (well below average — excellent)

Pros

✓Largest U.S. agent network
✓Strong bundle discount
✓Excellent in-person claims

Cons

⚠Not always the cheapest standalone home
⚠Limited online-only options

Verdict: Top choice for households that bundle home + auto and value a local agent.

Allstate

A.M. Best

A+

J.D. Power Claims

871 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.94 (about average)

Pros

✓Up to 25% bundle discount
✓Combined deductible on shared claims
✓Catastrophe-pro claims pipeline

Cons

⚠Higher average premiums
⚠Mixed satisfaction in non-bundle households

Verdict: Strongest pick when bundling home + auto — bundle discounts often offset higher base rate.

Erie Insurance

A.M. Best

A+

J.D. Power Claims

892 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.36 (well below average — excellent)

Pros

✓Guaranteed replacement cost option
✓Top claims satisfaction
✓Below-average premiums

Cons

⚠Limited to 12 states
⚠Agent-only quoting

Verdict: In Erie's footprint, it's consistently one of the best price-to-service combinations available.

Liberty Mutual

A.M. Best

J.D. Power Claims

850 / 1000

NAIC complaint

1.28 (above average)

Pros

✓RightTrack discount stacking
✓Wide product menu
✓Personalized coverage tools

Cons

⚠Below-average customer satisfaction
⚠Renewal increases common

Verdict: Works if you maximize discount stacking — otherwise comparison-shop annually.

Travelers

A.M. Best

A++

J.D. Power Claims

870 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.71 (below average — good)

Pros

✓Green-home credits
✓Solid bundle discount
✓Strong financial backing

Cons

⚠Smaller agent network
⚠Higher rates in coastal states

Verdict: Solid mid-tier carrier — particularly strong for sustainable / energy-efficient homes.

Chubb

A.M. Best

A++

J.D. Power Claims

888 / 1000

NAIC complaint

0.62 (below average — good)

Pros

✓Guaranteed replacement cost
✓Extended cash settlement
✓High-value home expertise

Cons

⚠Premium pricing
⚠Limited eligibility — homes typically >$750K

Verdict: Best in class for high-value homes — overkill (and overpriced) for standard properties.

Compare car insurance quotes in 60 seconds

Drivers can save an average of $847/year. See your rates from top carriers.

Get my free quote

Frequently asked questions

We synthesize four data sources: A.M. Best financial-strength ratings (can they pay claims?), J.D. Power home claims and customer satisfaction studies, the NAIC complaint index (relative complaints), and 2026 benchmark rate data across multiple home profiles.

Explore more home insurance topics

Ready to lower your homeowners premium?

Compare quotes from top home insurers in your state and see your bundle savings.

Get my home insurance quote

← Back to Home Insurance Hub